“Electoral Brawlage” examines the first election and inaugural address of each U.S. president from Washington to Trump. This project will conclude in December 2026.
If you like shootouts, car chases, dogfights, and American history, read Heartlanders!
Subscribe to get these articles via email. Become a paid subscriber to help me buy more books.
If you’re reading this, you were alive when it happened. And you’ll be telling your great-grandchildren how insane it was when it did. Let us begin.
The Mood in 2015
As the Obama years drew to a close, both sides of the aisle geared up for a fight to succeed the country’s first black president. The culture had changed swiftly and broadly in those eight years. Racism as a concept received a new interpretation, with powerful institutions declaring that it was only real racism if it came from whites with power against non-white minorities. Racism toward whites was then “reverse racism” and didn’t exist, in fact it couldn’t exist, and you couldn’t argue without getting screamed at by increasingly fragile people. This all happened, I was there.
Gay marriage was also legalized by the Supreme Court in the summer of ‘15, ushering in sweeping changes in laws across the country, and we’re still seeing new legal theories tested under the growing umbrella of the Obergefell decision. Until then it had strictly been a state matter.
And this doesn’t even touch the changes in government/business relations, foreign policy, etc. That’s just the culture side, with some legal instruments behind them. Broadly speaking, lefty populism was the loudest voice in the country, and it looked like the momentum was with the Democrats. Much like in 2008, they confidently assumed they could stunt-cast another “FIRST!” candidate and walk her into the White House, like Arsenal trying to score a goal on The IT Crowd.
Indeed, in April of 2016 even former president George W. Bush lamented to a group of his former staff and advisers that he feared he would be the last Republican president ever. That hit the news in July of that year. And for a lot of Republicans on the ground, they shared that fear.
The Democrat Primary
As payment for her service to the machine, former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton was backed by the Democrat establishment as the ultimate It’s My Turn girl, receiving the torch from the man who beat her eight years prior. This was it. A lifetime of political schmoozing and being cheated on by the whoringest president in history would finally pay off. She was owed this. She deserved it. The prophecy was written. It was known.
The main obstacle in her way was Senator Bernie Sanders (Vermont), an anomaly even amongst Democrats, as he was openly socialist (communist-lite) and had even honeymooned in the Soviet Union back in the day. His candidacy appealed to Reddit addicts and illiterate vibe junkies who received the bulk of their education from Tumblr. There were also a couple of smart people who backed him, I won’t downplay that either. This is just how it goes.
Fortunately for Sanders he was smart enough to oppose Hillary Clinton and the Democrats on the biggest stage possible so that he wouldn’t accidentally wake up sad enough to shoot himself in the back of the head twice with a shotgun. The Machine had to find other ways to rally around its preferred candidate so that people would, democratically, make the choice they were told to. Between the super-delegates and the inner workings of the DNC, the Hillary Train was able to strong-arm a reluctant endorsement out of Bernie Sanders at the convention that summer, and the final major primary obstacle was out of her way.
Ignoring the “also-rans,” the only real candidate outside of the Big Two that year was Martin O’Malley, who I think was the governor of Maryland. I’m not even going to look it up, he dropped out before the primaries actually started. If this account of the Democrat contest sounded kind of nuts, put on a helmet. You haven’t seen anything yet.
The Republican Primary
There were so many names here that I had to go back and look up the ones I forgot. This wasn’t just a case of Jim Bob Steve-O in Rainwater, Appalachia throwing his hat into the ring on accident because he filed his taxes wrong; there were seriously a dozen people who thought they were The Chosen One and that with the Republican Party in the shambles that it was, they could wrestle the crown out of the gutter and put it on. They weren’t slouches, either. At least, not all of them. Let me remind you who they were:
The Big Guns
Donald Trump. Businessman and reality TV personality. The ultimate outsider. Never held office before, everybody knew who he was, and he enjoyed widespread fame.
Ted Cruz, Senator from Texas. A first-termer but a popular voice in the Republican party, with backing from the establishment.
Marco Rubio, Senator from Florida. A party favorite and just as young in the Senate as Cruz, but without major party backing.
John Kasich, Governor of Ohio. A critical state for the national election but not a well-known entity. You’ve already forgotten his name, and history forgot him even faster.
Ben Carson, neurosurgeon. A ground-level conservative with notoriety on the talk radio circuit, and a good man.
The Small Potatoes
Jeb Bush, former Florida governor and brother to George W. Bush. Critically delusional, that’s all I have to say. “Please clap” was his greatest contribution to this cycle.
Christ Christie, Governor of New Jersey and quite possibly the fattest man alive. Committed an act of political murder-suicide against Rubio during the debates to ingratiate himself into the Trump Machine, only to be discarded as quickly as possible.
Rand Paul, Senator from Kentucky. Thought he’d inherit the momentum of his father’s movement of yesteryear. He did not. (Or maybe he did, it didn’t matter.)
Mike Huckabee, former Governor of Arkansas and Fox News Host. Lol. Lmao. How’s that 2008 “second place, it’s my turn” thing going for you, Mikey?
Rick Santorum, former Senator from Pennsylvania. Lol. Lmao. How’s that 2012 “remember me? it’s my turn” thing going for you, Ricky?
Carly Fiorina. Bay Area Girlboss and former CEO of Hewlitt-Packard. Who?
Rick Perry, former Texas governor. Hahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha. In 2012 he spaced out on an answer in a debate and blamed it on painkillers; in 2016 he fell asleep during a debate. He gone.
And I think Lindsey Graham actually took a shot here too. He missed. Wisconsin governor Scott Walker and former Louisiana governor Bobby Jindal went the same way, running out of money and support well in advance of Iowa. All that said, it was an incredibly deep bench of options, with a huge range of experience and qualifications. The Republicans were almost spoiled for options, but they had to compete with big backing from the party (who wanted Cruz or, to a lesser extent, Bush) and big money from Trump.
When the Iowa caucuses came in, it was pure chaos at first, as is almost always the case in caucuses. They’re less organized, less scientific, and more prone to manipulation than a recountable primary, and personally I think we should do away with them, but I don’t know everything. I just know that I sat through three straight Nevada caucuses and it was insanity all the way through, with 2016 being nuttier than a squirrel turd. People were ignoring all rules against electioneering and showing up loudly in pro-candidate gear at the polls. I’ve been to pro sports games that were calmer and better-organized.
That said, Ted Cruz won Iowa. Marco Rubio and Ben Carson combined with him to take the top fifty percent of the overall vote. Trump finished far behind, even though he enjoyed most of the media coverage to that point. He didn’t bother campaigning in Iowa all that much, and continued on to New Hampshire. He then won the next few contests, cleaning up handily in New Hampshire, South Carolina, Nevada, and Alabama.
By now the party machine was in an almost naked panic. The base was turning against them even harder than it had in 2012, when they told a bunch of evangelicals to vote for a Mormon. They then dug up that Mormon and trotted out Mitt Romney in front of a camera to look concerned and dignified, telling Republican voters that they couldn’t back this guy because he had bragged about having a lot of sex in the seventies, had a lot of failed marriages/businesses, and was rude to people on the news.
I think that was when I finally had to admit that the GOP base was correct: Mitt Romney didn’t understand who they were at all.
Since most of the others had dropped out, Romney outright told voters to get behind Cruz, Rubio, or Kasich for the remainder of the primary and try to force a floor vote at the party convention in order to prevent Trump from being the nominee. This did not work. Trump got enough delegates to win the vote, and at the convention that summer, he took over the party machinery, becoming the Republican candidate for…
The General Election
Dissatisfaction with the Big Two parties had never been higher. On the Left side, about a million and a half die-hards defected to the Green Party and backed Jill Stein. On the Right side, three times that number went Libertarian and voted for perennial candidate Gary Johnson. A third option, dark horse Evan McMullin, ran as an independent with a plan to snag a few key Mountain West states, hopefully preventing either Trump or Clinton from clinching 270 EVs.
I want to laugh at this but in the interest of full transparency, I got caught up in the McMullin wave while I was in Nevada. I was among those Sooper Serious GOP voters who didn’t want Trump (I backed Rubio) and thought he was a bad avatar for what our moral character should be. I wasn’t going to vote for Johnson (he and his VP, Bill Weld, were pro-abortion) and I wasn’t going to vote for the Dems or the Greens, so I got behind McMullin. He entered the race too late to make it onto the NV ballot and that state doesn’t allow write-ins, so I checked the box for “None of These” as a protest vote. That was my stupid “third-party” effort, my “do it once and don’t do it again” card, and I got it out of my system. Call it my hoe phase. Mi scusi.
This was it. Donald Trump and his VP, Mike Pence of Indiana, would face off against Hillary Clinton and her VP, Tim Kaine of Virginia. The most important election of our lifetime. Democracy was LITCHRULLY on the ballot, and it looked like we were going to get our FIRST woman in the White House, because hoooooo boy all the national polling showed her running away with it.
I spent the weeks in the run-up to the election just dreading it. If the news after Obama had been insufferable, the news after Hillary was about to become downright pornographic. Deepest bench in a generation and the Republicans blew it on the most beatable guy they could have picked. I made an announcement to all three hundred of my followers on Twitter that I was signing off for the day because the news was just going to annoy me, and I’d rather work on my books. (I was writing KILL THE BEAST at the time.)
But in all honesty, I didn’t last. A few hours into the count—the Eastern Time Zone had been closed for about two hours, IIRC—I logged into Twitter…
…and the whole world had lost its everloving excrement to the uttermost farthing.

Trump took South Carolina. He took North Carolina. He took Florida. Pennsylvania was starting to bleed red. West Virginia sure, but Georgia? Well, that’s okay, fine, whatever, there’s still the…Mid…West…wait, what do you mean Ohio? What do you mean Michigan? WHAT DO YOU MEAN WISCONSIN? What is happening?!
Nobody—absolutely nobody—whose job it is to professionally foresee this, actually foresaw it.
A note on the margins: Hillary ran away with the popular vote, which is meaningless in any contest where you are met with aggressive state lawfare anytime you attempt to block noncitizens from voting in highly populous blue states. It doesn’t matter that she appealed by broad margins to New York and California; she didn’t campaign widely enough, and Trump’s message resonated with voters in the Rust Belt who had been discarded during the Identity Politics Era of Democrat messaging. They showed up and delivered him key states in the Midwest that ultimately sealed Hillary’s loss.
The Civic Process
I have said this for the last ten years: the defeat of Hillary Clinton was not political for the American Left. It was religious. The prophecy had been declared, the outcome had been determined, all the Good and Smart people in the news and late-night television told all the right jokes about Trump and those wascally waciss wepubwicans, there was no way this didn’t end without swearing the FIRST woman president in 2017. So when it ended with her unmistakable loss, the cope flowed in with a concentrated purity level we haven’t seen in living memory. Before the Russian Collusion Hoax found its footing, the main vector of attack was the Electoral vote.
For a lot of Americans, who definitely take Muh Right To Vote seriously, this was the first time they learned how any of this actually worked, and a few of them showed up to protest the Electors confirming their state’s choice, because Muh Popular Vote, Lmao. Democracy is when the voters choose something but if they choose it wrong, you democracy them by changing their vote, and the more you change their vote to what you tell them, the more democracier it is.
As a result, there were seven total “Faithless Electors” who put the wrong names down when it came time to confirm their state’s choice. Three electors in Washington voted for Colin Powell, and another voted for "Faith Spotted Eagle,” a Sioux activist from South Dakota who opposed the Keystone XL pipeline. Of the remaining three Faithless Electors, one in Texas cast a vote for Ron Paul, another in Texas cast one for John Kasich, and the final voter in Hawaii cast a vote for Bernie Sanders.
The Electoral College, in accordance with our Constitution, accepted the will of the voters in the Union under their republican form of government, and confirmed Donald Trump as the 45th president of the United States.
The Speech
Much like Obama before him, Trump’s inaugural address was history-book-boilerplate, with a lot of stuff that was meant to sound good and inspiring, and other stuff you can take issue with. I remember I was at work that day, getting rained out in a truck, working on an outline for a fantasy book I’m never going to publish.
My brother texted me a couple of Donald Trump Bane memes with lines from the speech superimposed on them; it was the kind of populist stuff that catapulted him to the White House twice, but uh, hey, spoilers. Anyway, the shoe fit.
All that said, I’ve gone back and read it, and here are some things I liked. In retrospect, it wasn’t terrible, I was just butthurt that we didn’t get someone more sensible like Rubio. Everyone likes him now that he’s Trump’s Secretary of State, so hey, there’s still a chance, but we gotta see what the next few years look like. I’m getting ahead of myself.
This is your day. This is your celebration.
And this, the United States of America, is your country.
What truly matters is not which party controls our government, but whether our government is controlled by the people.
January 20th 2017, will be remembered as the day the people became the rulers of this nation again.
Well. Uh. Well.
For many decades, we’ve enriched foreign industry at the expense of American industry;
Subsidized the armies of other countries while allowing for the very sad depletion of our military;
We’ve defended other nation’s borders while refusing to defend our own;
And spent trillions of dollars overseas while America’s infrastructure has fallen into disrepair and decay.
We’ve made other countries rich while the wealth, strength, and confidence of our country has disappeared over the horizon. One by one, the factories shuttered and left our shores, with not even a thought about the millions upon millions of American workers left behind.
The wealth of our middle class has been ripped from their homes and then redistributed across the entire world. But that is the past. And now we are looking only to the future.
So…some stuff happened that made this hard to fulfill in his first term, and by the end of that term there was something of a worldwide fire to put out, but we’ll get to that another time.
We must protect our borders from the ravages of other countries making our products, stealing our companies, and destroying our jobs. Protection will lead to great prosperity and strength.
I will fight for you with every breath in my body – and I will never, ever let you down.
America will start winning again, winning like never before.
We will bring back our jobs. We will bring back our borders. We will bring back our wealth. And we will bring back our dreams.
Presented without comment.
The Bible tells us, “how good and pleasant it is when God’s people live together in unity.”
We must speak our minds openly, debate our disagreements honestly, but always pursue solidarity.
When America is united, America is totally unstoppable.
Absolute wholehearted agreement. The problem is we’ve given power in our country to people in our country who are not from our country and do not like our country. It is incumbent upon us to reverse this.
Do not let anyone tell you it cannot be done. No challenge can match the heart and fight and spirit of America. We will not fail. Our country will thrive and prosper again.
Agreed—though this is a spiritual matter, not a temporal one. It can’t be mandated or financed into existence. Americans must heal their spiritual woes first.
Your voice, your hopes, and your dreams, will define our American destiny. And your courage and goodness and love will forever guide us along the way.
It would prove to be an interesting couple of years.
Next week, we’ll take a look at how it wrapped up…
Visit Nauvoo Supply to order HEARTLANDERS, the most American novel I’ve ever written. It’s like if National Treasure happened during Fallout with G.I. Joes.
It’s short, it’s fast, it’s full of smarts and action, and you’ll love the characters.






